Combating illegal migration remains a major priority for the British government and many other European administrations. Across the continent, governments are strengthening border

controls, expanding deportation procedures and introducing stricter rules to prevent irregular arrivals. However, the debate over migration is considerably more complicated than questions of border security alone. Its impact on employment, economic growth, public finances and the sustainability of national economies is becoming increasingly important.

Spain provides a particularly interesting example of this dilemma. While the country has repeatedly faced waves of irregular migration, the arrival of foreign workers has also become an important factor behind its recent economic success. As political pressure for tighter immigration controls grows ahead of the November 29 parliamentary election, investors are increasingly concerned that a more restrictive approach could undermine Spain's economic performance.

The Spanish debate reflects a wider European challenge: how to protect national borders and maintain effective migration controls while ensuring that businesses have access to the workers they need.

Migration as an economic resource

The scale of immigration's contribution to Spain's economy is reflected in employment and GDP figures. According to the Bank of Spain, migrants accounted for approximately half of the country's economic growth between 2022 and 2025, representing around 1.7 percentage points of GDP expansion. They also contributed more than two-thirds of the increase in employment during the same period.

The number of foreign workers in Spain has increased by more than 1.2 million since 2022. Foreign-born residents now represent approximately 14% of the country's population of almost 50 million, while migrants account for more than 16% of people contributing to the social security system. Latin American workers make up roughly half of the foreign workforce.

These developments have helped Spain maintain a stronger economic performance than many other European countries. Its economy expanded by 2.6% in 2025, approximately twice the eurozone average. The government forecasts further growth of 2.6% in 2026 and 2.2% in 2027.

Immigration has also become important for sectors experiencing persistent labour shortages. Construction, agriculture, hospitality, tourism, transport and various services depend increasingly on foreign workers. Spain's housing crisis provides another example: the government argues that additional migrant labour is necessary to accelerate construction and address a shortage estimated at approximately 750,000 homes.

Deputy Prime Minister and Economy Minister Carlos Cuerpo has warned that significantly restricting immigration could weaken the labour market, reduce consumer spending and deprive public finances of an important source of revenue.

International financial analysts have expressed similar concerns. Oxford Economics has warned that stricter migration policies could reduce Spain's economic advantage over the eurozone, while Barclays has highlighted the potential consequences for labour-force growth.

Political pressure for stricter immigration controls

Despite the economic arguments in favour of migration, immigration policy has become one of the most politically sensitive issues in Spain.

Ahead of the November 29 parliamentary election, opinion polls suggest that the conservative People's Party (PP), led by Alberto Núñez Feijóo, could emerge ahead of Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez's Socialists. However, forming a government may require cooperation with Vox, a far-right party advocating considerably tougher immigration restrictions.

The People's Party supports a selective immigration system designed to address labour shortages but has criticised what it describes as uncontrolled migration. Vox proposes much more extensive restrictions, including reducing immigration, ending the regularisation of newly arrived migrants, increasing deportations and giving Spanish citizens priority in access to public services.

Vox argues that substantial tax reductions, lower public expenditure and reduced bureaucracy would improve economic competitiveness. However, some economists and investors fear that restrictions on foreign workers could have the opposite effect by limiting the availability of labour and reducing economic activity.

The political debate also reflects public dissatisfaction with the distribution of economic growth. Although Spain has achieved impressive headline economic results, many households have not experienced comparable improvements in their living standards. Housing affordability, rising demand for accommodation and pressure on public services remain significant concerns.

Some economists argue that rapid population growth has not been accompanied by sufficient improvements in productivity and income per capita. They also point to the expansion of relatively low-skilled employment as a potential structural weakness of Spain's economic model.

Consequently, the question is not simply whether immigration contributes to economic growth, but whether governments can ensure that its benefits are distributed more widely across society.

The difference between illegal and labour migration

One particularly important aspect of the Spanish debate is the distinction between irregular migration and legal immigration.

The need to combat illegal migration does not necessarily contradict the economic arguments for recruiting foreign workers. Governments can strengthen border protection, improve the effectiveness of deportation procedures and combat human trafficking while maintaining legal pathways for people whose skills and labour are needed by national economies.

Spain's experience demonstrates why these two dimensions should not automatically be treated as identical. A restrictive approach targeting illegal entry and criminal networks may be compatible with an immigration system that allows businesses to recruit qualified and appropriately authorised workers.

This distinction is relevant across Europe, including the United Kingdom. British policymakers face the challenge of controlling irregular arrivals while addressing labour shortages in sectors such as healthcare, social care, construction, agriculture and hospitality. The economic consequences of migration policy therefore extend beyond border management and directly affect employers, public finances and national competitiveness.

The wider European debate is also taking place against the background of demographic ageing, declining birth rates and growing demand for workers in several industries. For many European economies, attracting qualified foreign employees has become an important component of long-term economic planning.

Finding a balance between security and economic growth

Spain's experience illustrates the complexity of developing an effective migration policy. On the one hand, governments have a responsibility to maintain secure borders, enforce immigration legislation and respond to public concerns about irregular migration. On the other, foreign workers can make a substantial contribution to economic development, tax revenues and the sustainability of essential services.

The International Monetary Fund has also identified immigration-driven labour-force expansion as a major factor behind Spain's recent employment growth, estimating that migrants accounted for around three-quarters of cumulative employment gains between 2022 and 2025.

The challenge for European governments is therefore to develop migration systems that are both economically effective and politically sustainable. This means combining stronger enforcement against illegal migration with transparent recruitment procedures, integration programmes, recognition of professional qualifications and effective protection against labour exploitation.

Ultimately, Spain's experience offers an important lesson for the United Kingdom and the rest of Europe: migration policy cannot be assessed exclusively through the number of people entering a country. Its economic consequences, the needs of employers, the impact on local communities and the effectiveness of integration measures must also be considered.

A successful approach should protect national interests without unnecessarily weakening the labour force on which economic growth depends.

The article draws on reporting published by Reuters on 19 November 2026, alongside economic assessments by the Bank of Spain and the IMF. Photo by HrAd, Wikimedia commons.

UK News

Th e London Weekly

Culture

British Queen

 

British Queen celebrates