Breweries in Wales have voiced their apprehension over the proposed refundable bottles and cans fee, fearing it will harm their industry. Climate Change Minister Julie James has indicated her
intention to proceed with the introduction of a deposit return scheme in Wales, which would include glass containers. The scheme aims to boost recycling rates by charging a deposit on single-use containers such as plastic bottles and aluminium cans, which can be refunded upon return.
However, the chairman of Brewers of Wales expressed concerns that the scheme would put them at a disadvantage. While similar plans in Scotland have been postponed, the UK government has decided against including glass in its scheme after consultations. In a joint scheme planned between Wales and England, containers bought in one location could be returned in another. But if glass is excluded in England, the Welsh scheme would only apply to goods produced in Wales or directly imported.
Simon Buckley of Evan Evans Brewery, located in Llandeilo, Carmarthenshire, highlighted the additional bureaucracy the scheme would impose and the disadvantage it would create for smaller breweries. He also raised concerns about the practicality of the scheme, including the uncertainty surrounding the return of funds and the potential for fraudulent claims.
Opposition to the scheme came from Andrew RT Davies, leader of the Senedd Conservatives, who accused the Welsh government of trying to score political points against the UK government. Jo Golley of Keep Wales Tidy, however, supported the inclusion of glass, emphasizing the need for a clear and simple message that encourages public participation in recycling.
The climate change minister vowed to challenge the UK government on the issue, stating that the Internal Market Act should not allow one nation to disrupt the commerce of another. Jess Sargeant of the Institute for Government think tank explained that Scotland and Wales were challenging the UK government due to their dissatisfaction with the Internal Market Act's impact on devolved authority. While the Welsh government has not decided on legal action yet, it is reviewing the implications of the UK government's decision regarding Scotland's plans. Photo by Celinebj, Wikimedia commons.